5 Best Formulas for Babies Transitioning From Breast Milk

In this article

5 Best Formulas for Babies Transitioning From Breast Milk

Beyond breast milk: Exploring formula options that nourish and comfort your growing child

a woman in an orange jacket and blue shirt
By Staci Gulbin
a woman in a blue shirt standing in a field
Edited by Caitlin Snethlage

Updated October 6, 2024.

A baby laying on a bed drinking from a bottle.

Every feeding journey is unique, and formula is a safe, scientifically-developed option that helps millions of babies thrive. While breast milk is described as the gold standard, many of today's formulas are advanced nutritional solutions that support healthy development—not a compromise.

With the perfect balance of essential nutrients, vitamins, and beneficial compounds, our recommended formulas are designed to give you confidence in your feeding decisions. This lets you focus on what matters most—cherishing every moment with your little one.

» Ready to switch to from breastfeeding? Try wholesome, organic baby formula



Our Pick: Best Formulas for Babies Transitioning From Breast Milk

  1. Best overall formula for babies transitioning from breast milk: Else Nutrition Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula
  2. Best hypoallergenic formula for babies transitioning from breast milk: Enfamil® NeuroPro™ Infant Formula
  3. Best overall formula for babies transitioning from breast milk: Similac® 360 Total Care® Sensitive* Infant Formula
  4. Best organic formula for babies transitioning from breast milk: Happy Family Organic Infant Formula, Stage 1 Sensitive
  5. Best gentle formula for babies transitioning from breast milk: ByHeart Whole Nutrition Infant Formula


When and Why to Transition To Formula

Parents typically consider switching to formula when their baby is three to six months old. Common reasons for this transition include:

  • Returning to work, which can make keeping a consistent breastfeeding schedule challenging, especially for mothers who may not have adequate facilities or time for pumping during their workday.
  • Creating a more flexible feeding schedule that provides more freedom in daily activities while ensuring the baby's nutritional needs are fully met.
  • Addressing insufficient breast milk production, which can happen for many reasons, including hormonal changes, medication, or underlying health conditions that may impact milk supply.
  • Involving partners or family members in the feeding process, which not only provides the mother with much-needed breaks but also allows for bonding opportunities between the baby and other caregivers.

» Check out these tips for a gentle transition from breastfeeding

5 Best Formulas for Babies Transitioning From Breast Milk

Best overall formula for babies transitioning from breast milk

1


Outstanding
9.9
Else Nutrition Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula
Else Nutrition Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula
Else Nutrition Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula

Else Nutrition Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula

Your baby deserves the best

Price

$34.99


Volume

22 oz / 625 g


Age

12+ months

Else Nutrition Plant-Based Complete Nutrition Formula stands out as a superior option for babies transitioning from breast milk, offering a unique plant-based formula that closely mimics the natural composition of breast milk.

Its innovative blend of organic almonds, buckwheat flour, and tapioca maltodextrin provides a gentle, easily digestible formula that supports healthy growth and development.

The minimal processing and whole food ingredients make it an excellent choice for parents seeking a clean, allergen-friendly option for their little ones.

Over 90% whole food, minimally processed ingredients

Higher iron content than breast milk

Palatable taste and texture

Dairy, soy, and gluten-free, suitable for sensitive tummies

Not suitable for children under 12 months

Best milk-based formula for babies transitioning from breast milk

2


Excellent
9.5
enfamil neuro pro infant formula
a yellow container with a list of ingredients on it
a couple of containers of food sitting next to each other

Enfamil® NeuroPro™ Infant Formula

Price

$34.99


Volume

20.07 oz / 586 g


Age

0–12 months

Enfamil Neuro Pro is designed to mimic the nutritional composition of breast milk, with added components to support brain and immune system development. The inclusion of milk fat globule membrane (MFGM) and Enfamil's proprietary HuMO6 blend sets this formula apart in its attempt to replicate the complex benefits of breast milk.

Similar taste to breast milk

Features HuMO6 for immune health

Contains MFGM for brain health

Slightly thicker texture than breast milk

Not suitable for babies with cow's milk allergies

Best hypoallergenic formula for babies transitioning from breast milk

3


Great
9.3
Similac® 360 Total Care® Sensitive* Infant Formula
Similac® 360 Total Care® Sensitive* Infant Formula
Similac® 360 Total Care® Sensitive* Infant Formula

Similac® 360 Total Care® Sensitive* Infant Formula

Price

$35.19


Volume

20.1 oz / 570 g


Age

12–36 months

Similac Alimentum is a good option for those with milk protein sensitivities or allergies. This hydrolyzed formula breaks down milk proteins into smaller, more digestible components, significantly reducing the likelihood of allergic reactions.

Its unique composition helps manage colic symptoms related to protein sensitivity while providing essential nutrients for growth and development.

Iron-fortified

Contains DHA and ARA

Helps reduce colic symptoms

Strong, distinctive smell and taste

May cause darker, looser stools

Best organic formula for babies transitioning from breast milk

4


Very good
9.2
Happy Family Organic Infant Formula, Stage 1 Sensitive
Happy Family Organic Infant Formula, Stage 1 Sensitive
Happy Family Organic Infant Formula, Stage 1 Sensitive

Happy Family Organic Infant Formula, Stage 1 Sensitive

Price

$32.69


Volume

21 oz / 595 g


Age

0–12 months

Happy Baby Organics Infant Formula offers a clean, organic option for parents seeking a natural transition from breast milk. This formula stands out for its commitment to organic ingredients and prebiotics and probiotics to support digestive health.

The reduced lactose content and carefully selected nutrients aim to provide a gentle yet nourishing alternative to breast milk.

Free from GMOs, antibiotics, and artificial growth hormones

USDA Organic certified

Includes DHA and ARA

Some infants may have difficulty tolerating it

May not be suitable for babies with certain allergies

Best gentle formula for babies transitioning from breast milk

5


a jar of byheaart whole nutrition infant formula
a jar of breast milk with a blue lid
a nutrition label for vitamins and other foods

ByHeart Whole Nutrition Infant Formula

Price

$42


Volume

24 oz / 680 g


Age

0–12 months

ByHeart Whole Nutrition Infant Formula stands out for its use of organic, grass-fed whole milk and a patented protein blend that aims to replicate the easy digestibility and nutritional profile of breast milk.

Their commitment to clean ingredients and comprehensive clinical testing makes it a good choice for many parents,

Organic, grass-fed whole milk

Certified by Clean Label Project

Includes prebiotic GOS

More costly than other options

May not be suitable for babies with milk allergies



» Discover our expert tips for finding the right formula for your baby

How to Find the Right Formula

When selecting a formula for your transitioning baby, prioritize these essential elements:

1. Brain Health Components

Cognitive development is crucial in early infancy, making sure nutrients non-negotiable.

  • Look for DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) and choline
  • These nutrients support eye and brain development
  • Scientific studies confirm their importance for nervous system development [1]

» Don't want commercial options? Switch to natural and organic formula

2. Prebiotics and Probiotics

A healthy gut microbiome forms the foundation for overall wellness in infants.

  • Support immune and gut health
  • Help diversify the baby's gut flora
  • Reduce intestinal inflammation over time

3. Digestibility Factors

Easier digestion means happier babies and more peaceful days and nights.

  • Seek formulas with easily digestible compounds
  • Lactose is typically well-tolerated by most infants
  • Consider elemental formulas for babies with sensitivities

» Wondering if your baby is lactose intolerant? Watch out for these signs

4. Colostrum-Like Components

Mimicking the benefits of early breast milk can provide additional immune support.

  • Look for lactoferrin in the formula
  • Helps strengthen the baby's immune system
  • Provides similar benefits to colostrum in breast milk

5. Human Milk Oligosaccharides (HMO)

These complex carbohydrates play a vital role in infant health beyond basic nutrition.

  • Support immune health development
  • Stimulate beneficial gut bacteria growth
  • Improve intestinal barrier function

» Find out how nutrition can strengthen your child's immune system

Tips For Switching From Breast Milk to Formula

Transitioning your baby to formula requires a patient, consistent approach that prioritizes their comfort and helps them adapt smoothly.

  • Start Gradually: Replace one daily breastfeeding session with formula, choosing a mid-day feed. This slow approach helps babies adjust while maintaining familiar breastfeeding routines.
  • Combine Milk Types: Mix breast milk with formula in bottles, gradually adjusting the ratio over time. This eases the taste transition and helps prevent digestive issues.
  • Test Different Bottles: Try various bottle and nipple combinations until finding what works best. Some babies prefer specific shapes or flow rates, affecting their formula acceptance.
  • Keep Close Contact: Keep the same intimacy during formula feeds as breastfeeding. Skin-to-skin contact and eye connection help maintain the bonding experience and provide comfort during the change.
  • Time It Right: Introduce formula when your baby is content and alert, not overly hungry or tired. Positive early experiences with formula can impact overall success.
  • Share Feeding Duties: Let other caregivers join in formula feeding once established. This builds feeding flexibility and gives nursing parents much needed breaks.

» Discover the signs that indicate feeding issues in your baby

Ensure A Smooth Transition

Navigating the transition from breast milk to formula can be a bit overwhelming, but it doesn't have to be. By understanding the nutritional needs of your growing infant and selecting a high-quality formula that closely mimics breast milk, you can ensure a smooth transition that supports your baby's health and well-being.

» Support your baby's nutritional needs after breastfeeding with organic baby formula



The content and advice provided in this article are for informational purposes only and are not a substitute for medical diagnosis, treatment, or advice for specific medical conditions.

Always consult a pediatrician to understand your child's needs. The article expresses the views of the article's editor.



References

[1] L. A. Horrocks and Y. K. Yeo, “HEALTH BENEFITS OF DOCOSAHEXAENOIC ACID (DHA),” Pharmacological Research, vol. 40, no. 3, pp. 211–225, Sep. 1999, doi: 10.1006/phrs.1999.0495. Available: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10479465/